TOTPBOX vs 1Password

1Password is an all-in-one password manager that stores passwords, credit cards, notes, and 2FA secrets in cloud vaults protected by a Master Password and Secret Key. TOTPBOX takes a restrained, local-first approach: it focuses strictly on authentication (TOTP codes, recovery codes, and Passkey upgrade paths) with on-device AES-256-GCM encryption and never stores your passwords.

Based on 1Password's public documentation, checked . Vendors change their products, so confirm details in the sources below.

Feature comparison

CapabilityTOTPBOX1Password
PlatformsChrome extension for Chromium-based browsers on Windows, macOS, Linux, and ChromeOS. Native apps are planned.iOS, Android, macOS, Windows, Linux, and browser extensions
Where secrets liveAES-256-GCM encrypted vault inside the browser on your computerEncrypted in 1Password cloud vaults via master password + Secret Key
Product scopeFocused authentication companion; strictly zero passwords storedFull password manager storing logins, credit cards, secure notes, and files
Backup and syncPassword-encrypted export on every plan. Pro adds end-to-end encrypted sync across up to 5 devices; the server only sees ciphertext.Cloud synchronization included with all paid subscriptions
Browser autofillDetects one-time-code fields and fills the matching codeAutofills credentials and 2FA codes from browser extension
Passkey guidanceFlags accounts whose service supports passkeys and walks you through the upgradeStores passkeys in vault; no dedicated TOTP-to-passkey upgrade advisor
PriceFree. Pro is $4/month$2.99/mo individual, $4.99/mo families (annual billing; no free tier)

Choose TOTPBOX if

  • You prefer separating your authentication factor from your password storage (defense-in-depth).
  • You want a free, local-first authenticator that never mandates cloud synchronization.
  • You want visual tracking for which accounts are ready for hardware-bound passkeys.

Stay with 1Password if

  • You want a single unified vault that stores passwords, credit cards, documents, and 2FA codes together.
  • You manage family or enterprise credentials with role-based access delegation.
  • You need native mobile apps on iOS and Android today.

Moving from 1Password to TOTPBOX

Moving your 2FA accounts from 1Password into TOTPBOX lets you decouple your second factor from your primary password vault. Because 1Password can display your OTP secrets, you can migrate them directly or re-scan your setup QR codes.

  1. 1Sign in to the target service using 1Password to access its two-factor authentication settings.
  2. 2Choose to view or reset your authenticator app secret to display the setup QR code or text key.
  3. 3In TOTPBOX, select Add account and scan the QR code or enter the secret key manually.
  4. 4Verify the 6-digit code in TOTPBOX matches the code generated by 1Password.
  5. 5Store the service recovery backup codes inside TOTPBOX's encrypted recovery vault.
  6. 6Optional: Remove the one-time password field from 1Password to enforce security separation between passwords and 2FA.